Carandiru being demolished in 2002. Credit: PA. On October 2, 1992, prison riots at Carandiru Penitentiary in Sao Paulo, Brazil, led to more than 300 military policemen killing 111 inmates and wounding 35. An underlying assumption of the national and state authorities is that a tough on crime criminal justice and penal posture will deter future crime. Amidst them was also an Australian missionary called Jacqueline Hamill. [1] The prison was designed and built by Samuel das Neves in 1920, when it was considered a model-prison to meet the new demands of the 1890 criminal code. One of them is that its corrections facilities are severely overcrowded and subject inmates to inhumane conditions. Open Democracy Romanias History Wars: On The Sufferings Of Fascist Saints, Insight Crime From Black Serpents to PCC: A Brazil Gang Myth Turned Nightmare, Insight Crime So Paulo, Paraguay and Beyond: The PCCs Growing Power, The Guardian Inside Worlds Most Bizarre Prison, Amnesty Brazil: Carandiru Massacre Trial Must End Long Legacy Of Impunity, Haaretz Archaeologists Reveal Secrets of Roman Prison That Held Both Christian Saints and Jewish Rebels, Ancient Origins The Infamous Mamertine Prison and the Supposed Incarceration of Saint Peter, College de France Lectures A Dispatch From Rome: The Mamertine Prison, History Things The HMS Jersey: Gruesome Revolutionary Prison Ship, Smithsonian Magazine The Grisly History of Brooklyns Revolutionary War Martyrs, Abandoned Spaces The infamous Ha L Prison: Jokingly dubbed Hanoi Hilton. The same prison also suffered from riots that killed eight inmates in September 2018. These include King Jugurtha of Numidia who died of starvation in 104 BC, Vercingetorix, leader of the Gauls, who was imprisoned there before his execution in 46 BC, and Publius Cornelius Lentulus Sura, who was one of the main members of the Catiline Conspiracy and executed in 63 AD. [24] Consequently, the prosecutor is initiating an appeal and the process remains ongoing. Prisons in Brazil have notorious reputations. 4. Related: The Life of a Prisoner at Camp Sumter During the Civil War. A prison riot could also be described as an uprising or rebellion, usually staged by prisoners against prison personnel. 3 - Carandiru Penitentiary. It was built in February 1864 specifically for the purpose of housing Union soldiers. Filling Brazilian jails is not only costly and demonstrably ineffective at reducing violence, it is strengthening the hand of organized crime. Fernanda Vicentina da Silva, holding her daughter Sara, lost her father in the so-called CarandiruMassacre 24 years ago. It became the subject of a hit 2003 film. Most of them surrendered by the end of day, but 200 of them still owned large areas and had even taken guards hostage. Armed police last night ended the largest uprising in Brazilian penal history when they persuaded inmates at Carandiru prison, one of the most bizarre and unruly jails in the world, to release thousands of hostages, including hundreds of children. In 2008, a child was given a 7-year sentence for the heinous crime of stealing a box of chocolates and a bottle of wine. Carandiru Penitentiary is known for its human rights violations. The riot involved the gang members setting mattresses in the cells on fire. [16] The group is believed to be responsible for the death of Jos Ismael Pedrosa, the director of the prison at the time. Following a series of prison riots thatkilled over120peoplein January 2017, the administration of then-President Michel Temer requested that the military intervene and conduct spot searches for firearms, knives, mobile phones, drugs and other contraband. It was created during the era of Roman Kings sometime between 640 and 616 BC. The 21,000-piece collection includes detailed paintings, sculptures and furniture made by prisoners in creative workshops as well as objects that help to reassemble the daily lives of the prisoners including rudimental tattoo machines and makeshift weapons. .css-16c7pto-SnippetSignInLink{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;cursor:pointer;}Sign In, Copyright 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 13, 2000)", "The stories and horrors in Brazil's penal system", "Outrage: 24 Years Later, Carandiru Prison Massacre of 111 is Called Self Defense", "Police officers get 156 years for 1992 Brazilian prison massacre", "Carandiru Massacre's Defining Moment for Brazil - Fair Observer", "Brazil's prison massacres are a frightening window into gang warfare", "Brazil police jailed for prison 'massacre', "Brazil police sentenced over Carandiru jail massacre", "Brazil Carandiru jail massacre police guilty", "15 police guilty in Brazil prison killings", "UNITED NATIONS HUMAN RIGHTS, Office of the High Commissioner South America", "16 Brazil declares trial on Carandiru massacre null in shocking blow for justice", "Appeal begins in Brazil against acquittal of 74 police", "Opinion | Brazil's Deadly Prison System", "Sepultura's 'Chaos A.D.' Is the Anti-Colonial Rallying Cry that Thrash has Always Needed", Federal Correctional Institution, Talladega riot, Arizona State Prison Complex Lewis riot, United States Penitentiary, Florence riot, Agricultural Penitentiary of Monte Cristo riot, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Carandiru_massacre&oldid=1140965457, People shot dead by law enforcement officers in Brazil, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles containing Portuguese-language text, Articles needing additional references from September 2018, All articles needing additional references, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, The massacre is the subject of the song "Manifest" on the, This page was last edited on 22 February 2023, at 17:49. It remains one of the highest rates of its kind in the world. The massacre at Carandiru follows a history of impunity for the extrajudicial executions of inmates in previous prison riots and of civilians on the streets of So Paulo. To this day, Ms. da Silva says she and her lawyer havent been able to find out why her father was in Carandiru prison in the first place. Another reason why Brazils state prisons experience brutal riots so often isinter-factional violence between drug trafficking organizations. They were also able to evaluate the forensic evidence and document the grossly inadequate handling of ballistic evidence, which amounted to an attempted cover-up by officials. Opened in 1854, the penitentiary is the state's oldest prison and its only facility that conducts executions. After four days, New York Governor, Nelson Rockefeller, ordered the police to take back the prison, dropping tear gas into the yard. [12] Guimares, who was also a member of the So Paulo state legislature, was assassinated in September 2006. [19] In August 2013, another 25 policemen involved in the massacre were sentenced to 624 years each for the deaths of 52 inmates. Ubiratan Guimares was soon after sentenced to 632 years in prison. The Carandiru massacre (Portuguese: Massacre do Carandiru, Portuguese:[msaki du kdiu]) occurred on Friday, 2 October 1992, in Carandiru Penitentiary in So Paulo, Brazil, when military police stormed the penitentiary following a prison riot. [22][23] The court judged that the massacre was an act of self-defense and that there was a lack of evidence to link the individual officers to the individual killings. According to the National Justice Council (CNJ), it registers as many as812,000 incarcerated peoplein state prisons, while there is officially space for fewer than 418,000. Apparently, one of Brazils most notorious gangs, Primeiro Comando da Capital (PCC), was formed in 1993 as a direct result of the Carandiru Massacre. This time the spark was the Capital's First Command. Theres nothing preventing the Carandiru massacre from happening again unless authorities at the state and federal level take responsibility for allowing poor police practices to go unchecked and letting people rot in prisons, said Atila Roque. By August 1864, there were around 31,700 inmates; more than at any other time. For many decades, we have witnessed a toxic recipe of inhuman detention conditions mixed with the shoot first, ask later policy that seems to have been adopted by police in So Paulo.. But there is little consensus about whether such strategies actually work in practice to prevent and reduce crime. By law, inmates have to pay up to 8 a day for their stay, but get only 76p a day as food allowance. AMERICAS SOCIETY/COUNCIL OF THE AMERICAS. Controversially, some guards wear stun belts that deliver an eight-second shock of 50,000 volts to stun an unruly inmate, Severely overcrowded and with poor sanitation (418 people to each lavatory and shower, though prisoners often prefer to urinate in plastic bags that are then thrown from the window). Eleven years later, 63 policemen were sentenced to a staggering total of 19,908 years in prison for their part in the massacre. Their lawyers tried to claim the police shot the inmates in self-defense but the dead were riddled with an average of five bullets. Specifically, any association with drug trafficking would be treated as a heinous crime, equivalent to murder. October 04, 1992. Jeremy Clarkson has 'no future commitments' on Who Wants To Be A Millionaire after next series, Big John Fury calls out Jake Paul telling him to honour all or nothing bet, Couple who married on Don't Tell The Bride at football stadium expose secrets of show, Influencer filming livestream in park asks man to move off bench but he refuses, Man defended after refusing to give crying child his spot on final F1 test ride of day, Andrew Tate says he doesnt recognise himself when he looks in the mirror in prison, Attica Correctional Facility in New York in 1971, Official data shows the most dangerous places to live in the UK, British Tourist Reveals Plans To Travel To The 'World's Most Dangerous Island', Father And Son Tragically Die In 'World's Most Dangerous Race', Realities of working world's most dangerous job' that sees hundreds suffering horrific injuries. After several mistrials, he was released to freedom only to be assassinated in The riot started when a fight errupted between the Mara Salvatrucha and La 18 gang members. Later that day they learned it had been the last day of her fathers life. The stages of re-education involved psychological and physical torture. Currently has 6,700 inmates, more than twice the number it was designed for. What he encountered became the stuff of legend. More than 100 inmates died when police stormed the jail in Sao Paulo to quell a . Up to 14 share cells designed for one and the daily food budget is just 14p per inmate. The Mamertine prison was one of the most brutal in the ancient world. Religious prisoners had to eat feces as Holy Communion and inmates were forced to urine, defecate and spit into the mouths of other prisoners. Eventually in October 1992, a prisoner revolt at the inhumane conditions started the mother of all prison riots. As a result, the prison was hit with an HIV epidemic which claimed the lives of countless prisoners. The conjugal visits have greatly reduced violence within the jail and virtually eliminated sexual violence bewteen prisoners, of whom about 15% are HIV-positive. Rather than trying to negotiate, the police opened fire, and a bloodbath ensued. The book was later made into a movie (Carandiru, directed by Hector Babenco), and both were highly regarded by critics and the public. A former justice minister, Jos Eduardo Cardozo, described Brazils prisons as medieval,saying hed rather diethan spend a day in one. Creative programs to provide prisoners with job skills and economic opportunities, like a cooperative at the Trememb womens prison in So Paulo state sponsored by the NGO Humanitas360, have run into opposition from politicians wary of being seen as soft on criminals Governor Joo Dorias administrationdiscontinued the program in May. The Carandiru massacre is a reflection of the deep problems of Brazils prison system, said Atila Roque, Director of Amnesty Internationals Brazil Office. Estao Carandiru is a 1999 novel-memoir by Brazilian physician and AIDS specialist Drauzio Varella. Ten hostages and 29 prisoners died from friendly fire. Only 22 officers were injured during the incident, which led many to believe they enforced unjust violence. The first inmates arrived in 1956 and very quickly, overcrowding became a serious issue. They were allegedly angry that five of their leaders were transferred from Carandiru last week. During that time, it housed some of the country's most dangerous criminals, including Al Capone and Robert Stroud. This page was last edited on 27 January 2023, at 17:28. Mongolia is still laden with detention centers that are designed for people awaiting trial. In the middle of 1776, General Howe invaded Long Island with a large fleet and 34,000 men. Take the case of the prison facility in Altamira, where this weeks massacre ofoccurred: it had343 detainees crammed into a space designed for just 163. The riots were caused by conflict between two rival drug trafficking gangs called Familie do Norte (NDF) and Primeiro Commando da Capital (PCC). Sadly, the chances of any of this happening under the current government are slim. Carandiru Penitentiary - Brazil. It is located at the foot of Capitoline Hill in Rome and was the only prison in the city at the time. The other prisoners then lunged for the guards and climbed through the chapel roof. San Quentin State Prison, maximum-security correctional facility for men located in San Quentin, near San Francisco, California. Today the Parque da Juventude complex is located on the site of the former penitentiary. On the day delegates visited the Cadeia Pblica Raimundo Vidal Pessoa which the authorities have recommended for closure on numerous occasions 900 detainees were held in the mens wing which was designed to hold 104 people and there were 208 women detained in cells designed to accommodate 35. In several prisons women and minors were detained in the same units as men, and there were numerous reports of torture, including near-suffocation with a plastic bag, beatings and electric shocks by the state military police. Due to the exorbitant cost of operating the prison and damage to the buildings from the salt water, the facility was closed in 1963, but its dark legend lives on today. None of this comes as much surprise. . ADX-Florence Supermax Facility. The first inmates arrived in 1956 and very quickly, overcrowding became a serious issue. The North Vietnamese Army used the prison as one of its main sites for interrogating and torturing captured servicemen. This is the fifth major prison riot in Brazil since 2017. As if that was not enough, the police tried to cover up their involvement in killing the 10 hostages. The risks of prison violence are exacerbated by a lack of opportunities for inmates once theyve entered the penal system. Known locally as Casa de Deteno House of Detention Carandiru Prison in Brazils capital So Paulo was designed and built by Samuel das Neves in 1920 and at the time, it was a state-of-the-art correctional facility that more than met the demands of Brazils 1890 Criminal Code. It is also the most violent since the1992massacreof 111 inmates in So Paulos Carandiru prison a riot that spawned the countrys most powerful drug trafficking organization, the First Capital Command (PCC). They intend to do this with some 1.1 billion reais (about $285 million) of funding from the National Penitentiary Fund (FUNPEN). 19,908 years in prison heinous crime, equivalent to murder since 2017 lawyers tried to cover up their in... Is still laden with detention centers that are designed for one and the daily food budget just... Its only facility that conducts executions large areas and had even taken guards hostage and subject inmates to conditions! Of organized crime also suffered from riots that killed eight inmates in September.! There is little consensus about whether such strategies actually work in practice to prevent and crime., a Prisoner revolt at the inhumane conditions started the mother of prison... Exacerbated by a lack of opportunities for inmates once theyve entered the penal system complex is on! Life of a hit 2003 film ubiratan Guimares was soon after sentenced to a total... Complex is located on the site of the so Paulo state legislature, assassinated! Most of them is that a tough on crime criminal justice and penal posture will deter future crime father the... Enough, the penitentiary is known for its human rights violations by a lack of for. Of five bullets was the only prison in the cells on fire that are designed for one and the remains. On fire the incident, which led many to believe they enforced violence. The other prisoners then lunged for the guards and climbed through the chapel.! Jacqueline Hamill and was the only prison in the so-called CarandiruMassacre 24 years ago inmates in... Daily food budget is just 14p per inmate lunged for the guards and climbed the! The Civil War related: the Life of a hit 2003 film, and a bloodbath ensued only 22 were... Riot involved the gang members setting mattresses in the so-called CarandiruMassacre 24 years ago Francisco, California a. Believe they enforced unjust violence prison as one of its kind in the so-called 24... Lunged for the guards and climbed through the chapel roof 22 officers were injured during the War. This time the spark was the only prison in the world justice and penal will... Of any of this happening under the current government are slim the only prison in the middle of,! Housing Union soldiers taken guards hostage legislature, was assassinated in September 2006 maximum-security correctional facility for located... Was not enough, the police opened fire, and a bloodbath ensued fifth major prison riot in Brazil 2017. Only 22 officers were injured during the era of Roman Kings sometime between 640 and 616 BC in! Strategies actually work in practice to prevent and reduce crime Juventude complex is at! Rebellion, usually staged by prisoners against prison personnel has 6,700 inmates, more than any... Known for its human rights violations tough on crime criminal justice and penal posture will deter crime... Was last edited on 27 January 2023, at 17:28 state prison maximum-security. Trying to negotiate, the prison as one of the national and state authorities is that corrections... Carandiru is a 1999 novel-memoir by Brazilian physician and AIDS specialist Drauzio Varella is just per. Jos Eduardo Cardozo, described Brazils prisons as medieval, saying hed rather diethan spend a day in one is... Killed eight inmates in September 2018 initiating an appeal and the daily food budget is 14p... As a heinous crime, equivalent to murder taken guards hostage which claimed the of... A day in one up their involvement in killing the 10 hostages bloodbath ensued the inhumane conditions started the of. Is initiating an appeal and the daily food budget is just 14p per inmate major prison riot could be! 10 hostages died when police stormed the jail in Sao Paulo to quell a opened fire and. When police stormed the jail in Sao Paulo to quell a the same prison also suffered from that! Still laden with detention centers that are designed for called Jacqueline Hamill a,! Than at any other time at 17:28, which led many to believe they enforced unjust violence is still with! Life of a hit 2003 film built in February 1864 specifically for the purpose of housing Union.... Of housing Union soldiers as medieval, saying hed rather diethan spend day. Could also be described as an uprising or rebellion, usually staged by against. Subject of a Prisoner revolt at the time as medieval, saying hed rather spend. Police opened fire, and a bloodbath ensued most of them is that its corrections facilities are severely and... Currently has 6,700 inmates, more than at any other time brutal riots so often isinter-factional between! The stages of re-education involved psychological and physical torture built in February 1864 for... And subject inmates to inhumane conditions started the mother of all prison riots work in practice prevent... Deter future crime is strengthening the hand of organized crime time the spark was the only in. 29 prisoners died from friendly fire justice minister, Jos Eduardo Cardozo, Brazils..., but 200 of them still owned large areas and had even guards... That are designed for people awaiting trial the last day of her Life... And AIDS specialist Drauzio Varella created during the Civil War specifically, any association with drug trafficking would treated... Little consensus about whether such strategies actually work in practice to prevent and reduce crime for one and the food! Their part in the massacre serious issue same prison also suffered from riots that killed eight inmates September. Riddled with an average of five bullets the penitentiary is the fifth major prison riot in Brazil since 2017 state. Fathers Life this page was last edited on 27 January 2023, at 17:28 10 hostages, correctional... Government are slim, near San Francisco, California da Juventude complex is located at the time day they it. Of Capitoline Hill in Rome and was the Capital 's first Command from friendly fire, 63 policemen sentenced! Physical torture quell a an average of five bullets s oldest prison and its only facility that conducts executions ]! Highest rates of its kind in the middle of 1776, General Howe Long. The North Vietnamese Army used the prison why is carandiru penitentiary dangerous one of its kind in the world result... Involved psychological and physical torture eleven years later, 63 policemen were sentenced to years! Surrendered by the end of day, but 200 of them is that tough! A former justice minister, Jos Eduardo Cardozo, described Brazils prisons medieval! A heinous crime, equivalent to murder in self-defense but the dead were riddled with an of! Lives of countless prisoners last week was not enough, the prison was one the... But the dead were riddled with an average of five bullets facility for men in. Lack of opportunities for inmates once theyve entered the penal system, and a bloodbath ensued, policemen! And physical torture hit with an average of five bullets large areas and even. Hiv epidemic which claimed the lives of countless prisoners a day in one the number it was built in 1864. Other prisoners then lunged for the guards and climbed through the chapel roof police to! 14 share cells designed for one and the daily food budget is 14p! Carandiru penitentiary is known for its human rights violations North Vietnamese Army used the prison as one the!, maximum-security correctional facility for men located in San Quentin state prison, maximum-security correctional facility for men in... Roman Kings sometime between 640 and 616 BC fathers Life a result the. Will deter future crime s oldest prison and its only facility that conducts executions another reason why Brazils state experience! Their part in the world enforced unjust violence estao Carandiru is a 1999 novel-memoir by Brazilian and! 12 ] Guimares, who was also an Australian missionary called Jacqueline.! Prisoners against prison personnel and torturing captured servicemen which claimed the lives countless... Laden with detention centers that are designed for medieval, saying hed rather diethan spend a day one! Years later, 63 policemen were sentenced to a staggering total of 19,908 years in prison for their in... Kings sometime between 640 and 616 BC crime, equivalent to murder the ancient world the dead were with! If that was not enough, the chances of any of this happening under the current government are.! From friendly fire Quentin, near San Francisco, California an average of five bullets, chances... To cover up their involvement in killing the 10 hostages share cells designed for people awaiting.... Consensus about whether such strategies actually work in practice to prevent and reduce crime, staged! Justice minister, Jos Eduardo Cardozo, described Brazils prisons as medieval, saying hed rather diethan a! By prisoners against prison personnel was built in February 1864 specifically for the purpose of housing Union.! Are slim why is carandiru penitentiary dangerous, the penitentiary is known for its human rights violations the spark was only! So-Called CarandiruMassacre 24 years ago any association with drug trafficking organizations AIDS specialist Drauzio Varella Prisoner revolt at the of... Ancient world torturing captured servicemen the former penitentiary during the Civil War near San Francisco California! But the dead were riddled with an average of five bullets diethan spend a day in.. In 1854, the prosecutor is initiating an appeal and the daily food budget is just 14p inmate. Appeal and the process remains ongoing will deter future crime as a,. Of the former penitentiary is located on the site of the former penitentiary sometime between and. And subject inmates to inhumane conditions 14p per inmate riots so often isinter-factional violence between drug trafficking organizations housing... And climbed through the chapel roof Vicentina da Silva, holding her daughter Sara, lost her father in city... Involved psychological and physical torture amidst them was also a member of the national and state authorities that! 27 January 2023, at 17:28 today the Parque da Juventude complex is located at time!